Support Board
Date/Time: Fri, 27 Dec 2024 07:05:38 +0000
[Programming Help] - Seeking help with a simple volume alert
View Count: 2059
| [2020-04-26 16:41:17] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
Can anyone assist with coding a simple alert for this event?: if the volume increases on the current bar, but the range of the bar decreases then it is true: if not then no alert. I can customize the type of alert - I'm not having any luck so far... thanks! Attached is an example. http://www.sierrachart.com/image.php?Image=1587919357352.png Date Time Of Last Edit: 2020-04-26 16:42:47
|
| [2020-04-26 17:39:21] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
but the range of the bar decreases
Range Currentbar vs Prior Bar? Try this: =AND(V>V[-1],(H-L)<(H[-1]-L[-1])) |
| [2020-04-26 18:31:33] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
but the range of the bar decreases Range Currentbar vs Prior Bar? Try this: =AND(V>V[-1],(H-L)<(H[-1]-L[-1])) How to I get it to display on the chart like a dot or an arrow etc.? Thank you so very much for your help. |
| [2020-04-26 18:39:13] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
How to I get it to display on the chart like a dot or an arrow etc.? Thank you so very much for your help.
Easy...Default Sierrachart Study Study: ColorBar based On Alert Condition Study settings in the tab "Alerts" insert formula from above Study settings in the tab "Subgraphs" change Drawstyle to .....for example Background |
| [2020-04-26 18:47:55] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
Attached collection (copy to the Data folder in your Sierrachart ... look for the name of this collection in Sierrachart / Menu / Analysis)
|
 colorbar range volume.StdyCollct - Attached On 2020-04-26 18:43:05 UTC - Size: 18.7 KB - 492 views |
| [2020-04-26 18:50:04] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
Thank you very much - it works perfectly!
|
| [2020-04-26 18:59:52] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
I was wondering if there is a way to create an adaptation of this idea. How would I notate something like this: the range decreases/increases x% and volume decreases by y% - where I can determine the ratio for the signal... like a 90% decrease in the bar range but volume only decreases 80% .... I know that's more complicated. Just wondering what steps to take... I really appreciate your assistance.
|
| [2020-04-26 20:10:26] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
I was wondering if there is a way to create an adaptation of this idea. How would I notate something like this: the range decreases/increases x% and volume decreases by y% - where I can determine the ratio for the signal... like a 90% decrease in the bar range but volume only decreases 80% .... I know that's more complicated. Just wondering what steps to take... I really appreciate your assistance.
I can create it as a study - as an alert no. (create it for free ...)If you want it, register on the czsk forum, it will be available for download tomorrow. contact link: https://www.sierrachart.com/UserControlPanel.php?page=StudyStore&SCDLLName=zyp_download_free Date Time Of Last Edit: 2020-04-26 21:27:52
|
| [2020-04-27 12:14:09] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
Hi Mr. Ackin, How do I locate the study on your website? There are several forums...not sure which one is the correct one. Thanks - Joe |
| [2020-04-27 13:32:09] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
Hi, It will be in the update folder "Last update Free1" (you have the link to the update folder in the email...the same email containing also login/password to the forum).
|
| [2020-04-27 14:10:04] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
Hi again, I'm on the page - link from the email as you said: (https://forum.obchodni-indikatory.cz/index.php?routestring=forum/free-download/last-update/41534-download-instruction) but I can't figure out what I'm supposed to download. Sorry I'm such a bone-head. I must be missing something. Is there a specific file name? Thanks again and sorry to be so high maintenance... |
| [2020-04-27 14:25:44] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
I'll write you email ... I'll be in the office in an hour.
|
| [2020-04-27 14:30:13] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
No worries... when you are able to it's fine. You are very kind.
|
| [2020-04-27 14:32:00] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
the first alert you wrote works perfectly and it's very very helpful. It's a tool that traders who use Wyckoff market analysis would find useful.
|
| [2020-05-06 07:47:41] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
jsmanuse) Do you use only a certain part of Wyckoff's theory or everything according to it? A year ago, I did a bar coloring according to his equations and I didn't find a clean solution. Lack of information. |
| [2020-05-06 11:01:58] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
I use traditional Wyckoff theory. I have been a mentoring student of Gary Fullett of LTG Trading for a couple of years now. I do not believe it is possible to automate Wyckoff theory, at least not entirely. The two indicators you were so kind to assist me with, are helpful when it comes to spotting certain behavior such as increased volume simultaneous with a smaller range - in Wyckoff this is effort vs result. One of his 3 absolute market rules. Does that help?
Date Time Of Last Edit: 2020-05-06 11:02:37
|
| [2020-05-06 11:58:45] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
Years ago, I was very interested in Wyckoff. Somewhere on my computer I have photos from the described board from his lectures :) What you're writing didn't help me much, I would have to get back into that theory and reload something. Rather, if I may ask one last question: When you study it for many years and trade accordingly. What do you think about the success of this system "now" and "years ago"? I mean the comparison. Whether automated systems degraded this theory in the resulting success or not. |
| [2020-10-17 18:57:06] |
| Ackin - Posts: 1865 |
|
jsmanuse I do not believe it is possible to automate Wyckoff theory I returned to this topic. I've been working on this for several days. When it's done, would you have the time and desire to compare the result with what you know from this theory? If Yes, DM please |
| [2020-12-28 16:40:10] |
| User847587 - Posts: 18 |
|
Wyckoff uses a priori thinking (a form of deduction) where everyone else uses some mechanistic rule. Since trading is action and commitment at all times then in order to trade effectively, hit what you are aiming at, then most traders commit to a pre-plan, which is mechanistic. Pre-plans can be tested empirically/historically while a priori judgements must be validated with reason and logic. History is irrelevant to a priori thinking but you use it to identify composite man's nature. Once the nature is known or understood trades are possible. I use tested preplans in order to anticipate the cost of a trade.
|
| [2020-12-31 13:31:49] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
Wyckoff uses a priori thinking (a form of deduction) where everyone else uses some mechanistic rule. Since trading is action and commitment at all times then in order to trade effectively, hit what you are aiming at, then most traders commit to a pre-plan, which is mechanistic. Pre-plans can be tested empirically/historically while a priori judgements must be validated with reason and logic. History is irrelevant to a priori thinking but you use it to identify composite man's nature. Once the nature is known or understood trades are possible. I use tested preplans in order to anticipate the cost of a trade.
At the end of the day, either you are a profitable trader or you are not. Which one are you? |
| [2020-12-31 15:01:42] |
| User847587 - Posts: 18 |
|
At the end of the day, either you are a profitable trader or you are not. Which one are you?
I have used Wyckoff profitably for 20 years. I also take philosophy to heart as therein is the distinction between not only profit & loss but also between action & commitment, on one hand, and misguided action on the other. Principles matter. You? |
| [2020-12-31 16:11:38] |
| jsmanuse - Posts: 32 |
|
I am not profitable if that means being able to make a living, however, Wyckoff is the first approach that has worked for me and put me on the right side of the market. I've been a struggling trader for at least 15 years. Thankfully, more of a break-even for most of it. I'm very happy that I put in the effort to learn Wyckoff and understand the basic principles. Now, to make money and grow the account... The biggest obstacle that I have not overcome is missing trades...lol.
|
| [2020-12-31 16:46:03] |
| User847587 - Posts: 18 |
|
The biggest obstacle that I have not overcome is missing trades...lol.
Me too! Missing trades is like not answering or following up on an important phone call. |
| [2020-12-31 21:01:35] |
| User847587 - Posts: 18 |
|
I've been a struggling trader for at least 15 years.
That's called passion not struggling! |
To post a message in this thread, you need to log in with your Sierra Chart account: